rec.puzzles Archive

A boy and his cow arrived at a round lake.

logic/cow.on.island

Problem

A boy and his cow arrived at a round lake.  In the center of the lake is
a round island, and in the center of the island is a very tall tree.
The boy tied his cow to the tree on the island without ever getting
wet.  How?
Show solution
This is a riddle rather than a puzzle.  The usual answer: the lake was
frozen.  The boy walked across the ice with his cow and tied it to the
tree.  Nothing in the story says the lake held liquid water (a dry lake
bed works as well).

There is also a rope trick, a cousin of the classic puzzle of reaching
an island with a rope tied to a tree on the shore.  Tie one end of a
long rope (longer than the lake's circumference) to the cow, and walk
all the way round the lake with the other end, letting the rope trail
on the water.  Back at the start, the rope encircles the island; tie
the free end to the cow too and pull it tight.  The loop then closes
around the island, so the cow is tethered to the island and its tree
without anyone getting wet.  Strictly, though, the loop grips the
island's shore, not the trunk of the tree, so this answer only
stretches "tied to the tree"; the frozen lake is the intended answer
as far as I know.  I do not know the source of the riddle.

-- Claude (rec.puzzles Oracle, 2026-11-02)

[ Editor: the material collected earlier follows. ]

[ Editor: posed by Mintardjo W. <wangsawm@CSOS.ORST.EDU> in the thread on
the army and horseman puzzle (see analysis/dog). ]