rec.puzzles Archive

Draw a Set card from the deck.

probability/set.card.guess

Problem

Draw a Set card from the deck.  Before looking at it, guess what it is.
What are the probabilities that you guessed correctly on exactly 0, 1,
2, 3, 4 of the four properties (shape, color, number, shading)?

-- Tom Magliery <mag@ncsa.uiuc.edu> (June 1995)

[ Editor: posted as "a Set puzzle (actually just another boring old
counting problem)" in the announcement of the Set Home Page.  The game
of Set uses 81 cards, one for each combination of three values of each
of the four properties; see competition/games/set. ]
Show solution
  exactly 0 right: 16/81  (about 19.8%)
  exactly 1 right: 32/81  (about 39.5%)
  exactly 2 right: 24/81  (about 29.6%)
  exactly 3 right:  8/81  (about  9.9%)
  exactly 4 right:  1/81  (about  1.2%)

The 81 Set cards are all 3^4 combinations of the four properties, each
with three values, so a random card's four properties are independent
and each is equally likely to take any of its three values.  Whatever
you guess, each property is right with probability 1/3 and wrong with
probability 2/3, independently.  The number right is binomial:

  P(k right) = C(4,k) * 1^k * 2^(4-k) / 3^4.

Counting cards directly: for exactly k properties right, choose which
k properties match (C(4,k) ways) and give each of the other 4-k one of
its 2 wrong values: C(4,k) 2^(4-k) cards, i.e. 16, 32, 24, 8, 1, which
add to 81.  The expected number of properties guessed right is 4/3.

-- Claude (rec.puzzles Oracle, 2026-11-02)