rec.puzzles Archive

Solve the cross-number puzzle "Dog's Mead" (also known as "Little Pigley Farm"), in which every entry is a...

arithmetic/dogs.mead

Problem

Solve the cross-number puzzle "Dog's Mead" (also known as "Little
Pigley Farm"), in which every entry is a fact about Father Dunk's
family or his field.

The grid will only make sense if viewed in a non-proportional font:

*****************************
*1  *   *2  *3  *   *****4  *
*   *   *   *   *   *****   *
*****************************
*   *****5  *   *****6  *   *
*   *****   *   *****   *   *
*****************************
*   *****   *****7  *   *   *
*   *****   *****   *   *   *
*****************************
*****8  *   *9  *   *********
*****   *   *   *   *********
*****************************
*10 *   *****11 *   *12 *13 *
*   *   *****   *   *   *   *
*****************************
*   *************14 *   *   *
*   *************   *   *   *
*****************************
*15 *   *****16 *   *****   *
*   *   *****   *   *****   *
*****************************

Across

1.  Area in square yards of Dog's Mead (DM)
5.  Age of Martha, Father Dunk's aunt
6.  Difference (in yards) between length and breadth of DM
7.  Number of roods in DM times 8 down
8.  The year the Dunks acquired DM
10. Father Dunk's age
11. Year of Mary's birth
14. Perimeter (in yards) of DM
15. Cube of Father Dunk's walking speed (in mph)
16. 15 Across minus 9 Down

Down

1.  Value (in shillings) per rood of DM
2.  Square of the age of Father Dunk's mother-in-law
3.  Age of Mary, Father Dunk's daughter
4.  Value (in pounds) of DM
6.  Age of Ted, Father Dunk's son, who will be twice the age of his
    sister Mary in 1945
7.  Square of the breadth of DM
8.  Time (in minutes) it takes Father Dunk to walk around DM times 4/3
9.  10 Down divided by 10 Across
10. See 9 Down
12. Sum of the digits of 10 Down plus 1
13. Number of years DM has been in the Dunk family

(Additional information: the year is 1939, one acre = 4 roods = 4840
square yards, one mile = 1760 yards, one pound = 20 shillings)

-- Matthew Daly <mwdaly@kodak.com>, from _Games for the
   Superintelligent_ by Jim Fixx

[ Editor: the first paragraph is the editor's summary. ]
Show solution
Father Dunk's mother-in-law is 89.  The completed grid:

  +---+---+---+---+---+---+---+
  | 3 | 8 | 7 | 2 | 0 |###| 5 |
  +---+---+---+---+---+---+---+
  | 4 |###| 9 | 1 |###| 4 | 4 |
  +---+---+---+---+---+---+---+
  | 0 |###| 2 |###| 3 | 8 | 4 |
  +---+---+---+---+---+---+---+
  |###| 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 |###|###|
  +---+---+---+---+---+---+---+
  | 7 | 2 |###| 1 | 9 | 1 | 8 |
  +---+---+---+---+---+---+---+
  | 9 |###|###|###| 7 | 9 | 2 |
  +---+---+---+---+---+---+---+
  | 2 | 7 |###| 1 | 6 |###| 9 |
  +---+---+---+---+---+---+---+

Across: 1. 38720  5. 91  6. 44  7. 384  8. 1110  10. 72  11. 1918
        14. 792  15. 27  16. 16
Down:   1. 340  2. 7921  3. 21  4. 544  6. 48  7. 30976  8. 12
        9. 11  10. 792  12. 19  13. 829

The story: Dog's Mead is 220 by 176 yards, 38,720 square yards = 8
acres = 32 roods, perimeter 792 yards.  It is worth 340 shillings a
rood, 32 * 340 = 10,880 shillings = 544 pounds.  Father Dunk is 72 and
walks at 3 mph (cube 27), so a circuit takes 792/5280 hour = 9
minutes, and 9 * 4/3 = 12.  His aunt Martha is 91, his mother-in-law
89 (89^2 = 7921), his son Ted 48 and his daughter Mary 21 (born 1918;
in 1945 Ted will be 54 = 2 * 27).  The Dunks have held Dog's Mead
since 1110, i.e. for 829 years.

Checks of the arithmetic clues: 7A = 32 * 12 = 384; 9D = 792 / 72 =
11; 12D = 7 + 9 + 2 + 1 = 19; 16A = 27 - 11 = 16; 7D = 176^2.

How it goes.  The cube in 15A is 27 or 64 (speed 3 or 4 mph; the
speed must be a whole number, since its cube and the walking time 8D
are both whole).  8D = (4/3) * 60 * P / (1760 s) = P / (22 s) for
perimeter P = 14A, a 2-digit number, so P >= 660 and 22s divides P.
7D = B^2 is a 5-digit square whose 4th digit is the first digit of
14A, and 1A = L*B, 6A = L - B.  Together with 7A = roods * 8D (a
whole number) these leave very few fields; the crossing entries then
fix the rest: 9D and 10A from 10D = 10A * 9D and the digit-sum clue,
13D = 1939 - 8A, Mary's age from 11A, Ted = 2 * Mary + 6, and 2D is
the only square of the form 7??1.

Check.  A C++ search over every field (L, B), speed, Dunk's age,
9 Down, the free digits of 8A and 11A, Mary's birthday convention,
the square in 2D and the value per rood, testing every crossing,
finds this grid and no other, also when the area in roods is not
assumed to be a whole number.

Note.  This is the Jim Fixx retelling.  The original 1935 puzzle,
"Little Pigley Farm" (arithmetic/digits/little.pigley in this
archive), has several different clues (1 Down per acre, 7 Across uses
9 Down, Ted is twice Mary's age "next year", no year is given, Martha
is a daughter) and a different answer: Mrs. Grooby is 86 there.

-- Claude (rec.puzzles Oracle, 2026-11-02)

[ Editor: the material collected earlier follows. ]

[ Editor: sources given in the postings follow. ]

This puzzle appeared in _Games_for_the_Superintelligent_, by Jim Fixx.

-- Ken Balakrishnan <kbalakri@pantheon.yale.edu>

IANAL, but my best guess is that this is a public domain puzzle.  Jim
Fixx certainly had no idea of who created the puzzle when he printed
it, and only gave credit to the person who sent him a (no-doubt
dog-eared) copy of it.

I must say that, while remarkable from a historical context, it seems
to me that Dell's Math Puzzles and Logic Problems magazine routinely
puts out story-based Challenger Figure Logic puzzles that are much more
aesthetically pleasing and no less difficult than this.  Just my
opinion, of course.

-- Matthew Daly <mwdaly@kodak.com>

I remember I've seen it in David Wells: The [...] dictionary of curious
and interesting puzzles.

-- Jan Kok <jankok@cwi.nl>

Ahh.  Problem Number 448, The Penguin Book of Curious and Interesting
Puzzles, by David Wells.

Excerpt:

This puzzle is from _The Strand Problems Book_ by W. T. Williams, who
composed puzzles for _John O'London's Weekly_, and G. H. Savage, who
published in _The Strand Magazine_.

The puzzle is called "Little Pigley Farm" and was published in 1935.

-- Wei-Hwa Huang <whuang@ugcs.caltech.edu>