rec.puzzles Archive

To each of the following questions, exactly one of the alternatives is true.

logic/self.ref.small

Problem

To each of the following questions, exactly one of the alternatives is
true.  Which one?

1. The first question whose answer is B is question
   (A) 2
   (B) 3
   (C) 4
   (D) 5
   (E) 6

2. The only two consecutive questions with identical answers are questions
   (A) 2 and 3
   (B) 3 and 4
   (C) 4 and 5
   (D) 5 and 6
   (E) 6 and 7

3. The last question with the same answer as this one is question
   (A) 10
   (B) 9
   (C) 8
   (D) 7
   (E) 6

4. The number of questions with the answer A is
   (A) 0
   (B) 1
   (C) 2
   (D) 3
   (E) 4

5. The answer to this question is the same as the answer to question
   (A) 10
   (B) 9
   (C) 8
   (D) 7
   (E) 6

6. The number of questions with answer A equals the number of questions
   with answer
   (A) B
   (B) C
   (C) D
   (D) E
   (E) none of the above

7. Alphabetically, the answer to this question and the answer to the
   following question are
   (A) 4 apart
   (B) 3 apart
   (C) 2 apart
   (D) 1 apart
   (E) the same

8. The number of questions whose answers are vowels is
   (A) 2
   (B) 3
   (C) 4
   (D) 5
   (E) 6

9. The number of questions whose answer is a consonant is
   (A) a prime
   (B) a factorial
   (C) a square
   (D) a cube
   (E) divisible by 5

10. The answer to this question is
   (A) A
   (B) B
   (C) C
   (D) D
   (E) E

Small S.R.A.T., composed by Martin Henz, using Oz.  Improvisation on a
theme by Jim Propp.
Show solution
The answers are

   1 C   2 D   3 E   4 B   5 E   6 E   7 D   8 C   9 B   10 A

and this is the only solution: a C++ program tried all 5^10 =
9,765,625 answer sheets and found that this is the only one in which,
for every question, exactly one alternative is true and it is the one
chosen.

Check, question by question:

 1. C (4): the first B answer is question 4; questions 1-3 are C, D, E.
 2. D (5 and 6): 5 and 6 are both E, and no other neighbouring pair
    agrees (C D E B E E D C B A).
 3. E (6): the answers E are questions 3, 5, 6; the last is 6.
 4. B (1): only question 10 is answered A.
 5. E (6): question 5 is E, as is question 6; questions 10, 9, 8, 7
    are A, B, C, D.
 6. E (none of the above): there is one A, against two B's (4, 9),
    two C's (1, 8), two D's (2, 7) and three E's (3, 5, 6).
 7. D (1 apart): questions 7 and 8 are D and C.
 8. C (4): the vowel answers are questions 3, 5, 6 (E) and 10 (A).
 9. B (a factorial): six answers are consonants, and 6 = 3! is not a
    prime, a square, a cube or divisible by 5.
10. A: the only A.

How I read the questions: in question 3, "the last question with the
same answer as this one" is taken among the other questions; in
question 9, the factorials are 1, 2, 6, 24, ..., and 0 and 1 count as
squares and cubes.  The solution above satisfies the questions under
other readings of these points too; uniqueness was checked under the
readings stated.

-- Claude (rec.puzzles Oracle, 2026-11-02)

[ Editor: the material collected earlier follows. ]

The "Small SRAT" that I posted was erroneous.  Thanks to Dean Hickerson
<dean@Math.UCDavis.Edu> for pointing it out.  Here comes the correct one.

-- Martin Henz <henz@dfki.uni-sb.de>, April 1996

[ Editor: the problem above is the corrected version.  The erroneous
first version began "The answer to each of the following questions is
either A or B or C or D or E. What are the answers?" and differed in
question 5, whose alternatives were (A) 2, (B) 3, (C) 4, (D) 5, (E) 6.
For a longer test of the same kind see logic/self.ref.test. ]